Page 4 of 81

Re: A French Book Reading Resource

Posted: Tue Feb 26, 2019 1:17 am
by MorkTheFiddle
Carmody wrote:I have hopes people will use this thread to discuss what they have read or seen. Specifically, MorktheFiddle suggested the movie
Bande à part
which I took out from the library and which I have to admit I did not get....at all. You loved it. I totally respect your tastes and your love of it but I did not "get it." Could you please explain what it is that I am missing?

Note: this post has spoilers of a sort.

It has been ten years or more since I saw Bande à part, so I remember only a few parts with clarity, plus I remember the fact that I liked it. But here's a thumbnail:

Lucky for me, when I watched Bande à part, Youtube wasn’t drowning in movie scenes from all over, if there even was a Youtube, so the [SPOILER-->] dance sequence came on me by surprise. The sequence in a nutshell shows my fondness for the movie. Three insouciant young misfits*, refreshingly seem like real people doing real things, often without much forethought. Crime capers are often so grim, the criminals are so dark, the production seems so movie-ish. None of that is true for this movie. Well, except [SPOILER-->] the ending. In short, what engaged me about the movie was the realistic characterization of the three amiable principals and the plot that was both unlikely and plausible at the same time.

* True, younger actors might have conveyed this a little better.

Hope this helps.

Re: A French Book Reading Resource

Posted: Tue Feb 26, 2019 2:02 am
by Carmody
Many thanks.
Yes the dance sequence is a really good one.
;)

Re: A French Book Reading Resource

Posted: Tue Feb 26, 2019 2:37 pm
by PfifltriggPi
Je vais copier ce que j'ai dit sur mon registre au sujet du livre que je viens de terminer, si il y a quelqu'un qu'en est intéressé.

PfifltriggPi wrote:J'ai enfin terminé L’Étranger d'Albert Camus ce matin. Il ne s'est pas terminé comme j'aurais attendu. J'aime Albert Camus primairement pour ses pouvoirs de description complètement incroyable et ils ne se montrent pas autant dans L'Étranger que dans La Chute ou L'Été deux que je préfère. Je l'ai trouvé en peu difficile a commencer aussi mais il s'est amélioré beaucoup quand j'ai progressé. En général, oui, je l'ai aimé.

Re: A French Book Reading Resource

Posted: Mon Mar 04, 2019 3:49 pm
by Carmody
Book Reading Update:

Have just finished Je l'aimais by A. Gavalda and would give it a 3/10 rating. It concerns a father-in-law talking to his daughter-in-law about love affairs he has had and why he would never divorce.

As noted previously I also read 35 Kilos d'espoir A. Gavalda which I found to be about a 4/10.

While both books got low ratings from me, I totally respect the fact that MorktheFiddle very much likes this author so don't be put off by these reviews, rather, just try other books by this author.

Whether I like a book or not is not that big a deal since I use my readings for vocabulary acquisition. So I don't really lose either way.

Have also recently finished with Jeux interdits, a movie about a very young girl left homeless by the war.

I read the books and view DVDs because I am interested in the French sensibility and what they tell me about it. One thing for sure is that the French are far more willing to end their books and films on a sad note than the Americans. The Americans love their happy endings; it is almost a prerequisite. The French see things differently and I am interested in the difference.

If people have questions, please feel free to ask.

Re: A French Book Reading Resource

Posted: Mon Mar 04, 2019 6:10 pm
by zjones
I am reading Changer l'eau des fleurs by Valérie Perrin. It's very reflective and personal, a perfect read when you want have some quiet time to yourself and a cup of tea. Because the book is about a woman who works in a cemetery, there are lots of reflections about life and death. Again, this is not literature, just a simple book.

Re: A French Book Reading Resource

Posted: Mon Mar 04, 2019 6:16 pm
by zjones
I am looking for recommendations for simple French books or poems, literature or otherwise. I greatly appreciate authors who know how to describe someone or something with the right words, but don't linger on descriptions for more than a few sentences at a time. As for poetry, I prefer poems about life, nature and emotions. You can recommend specific poems to me if there are any you like.

Overall I'd like to branch out into literature but something that's easy to read and sensitive. (Side note, I like memoirs too.)

Thanks for any suggestions!

Re: A French Book Reading Resource

Posted: Mon Mar 04, 2019 6:47 pm
by Carmody
by zjones » Mon Mar 04, 2019 7:10 am
I am reading Changer l'eau des fleurs by Valérie Perrin. It's very reflective and personal, a perfect read when you want have some quiet time to yourself and a cup of tea. Because the book is about a woman who works in a cemetery, there are lots of reflections about life and death. Again, this is not literature, just a simple book.
I always prefer simple; absolutely. Will get back to you with suggestions.

Re: A French Book Reading Resource

Posted: Mon Mar 04, 2019 7:31 pm
by MamaPata
I also read Je l’aimais recently and I wasn’t convinced. I wasn’t totally convinced by the premise but I was open to it. It didn’t really deliver for me. However, I think for a language learner it’s a useful option. It’s very short and quite simple.

I also recently read Le dernier des nôtres and Le confident, which are both psychological dramas/thrillers partly set during the Second World War. (By two different authors. My reading them one after the other was coincidence). I really didn’t like either of them and found some stuff very problematic.

I’ve got Stupeur et Tremblements out from the library and I’ll read Les Hirondelles de Kaboul for the forum book group but based on the blurbs, I’m not sure they’re going to do it for me.

Re: A French Book Reading Resource

Posted: Tue Mar 05, 2019 12:51 am
by MorkTheFiddle
Carmody wrote:Book Reading Update:

Have just finished Je l'aimais by A. Gavalda and would give it a 3/10 rating. It concerns a father-in-law talking to his daughter-in-law about love affairs he has had and why he would never divorce.
As noted previously I also read 35 Kilos d'espoir A. Gavalda which I found to be about a 4/10.
While both books got low ratings from me, I totally respect the fact that MorktheFiddle very much likes this author so don't be put off by these reviews, rather, just try other books by this author.

Hah! I loved her volume of short stories, Je Voudrais que quelqu'un m'attende quelque-part. :) Her first (?) novel, Ensemble c'est tout, was a big disappointment to me (2/10 maybe), though I finished it (hoping it might get better, I guess). Then in 2008 she published La Consolante, which I found unreadable (0/10), and stopped reading it after about 10-20 pages. After that, I gave up on her work, and have never read Je l'aimais or 35 Kilos d'espoir. I don't follow review sites like Good Reads or Babelio, and I don't know if there is a consensus about Gavalda's work, or whether there are any other readers who liked her first effort a lot but not what followed at all.
Another writer, not French, however, who struck me the same way was Frank Herbert, author of the science fiction classic, Dune. I loved Dune, yawned through the sequel, never read the later work at all. Maybe I should sit down some day and list the books, fiction and nonfiction, classic and non-classic, to put my opinion of Gavalda and other contemporary writers in perspective. Seems like a lot of unnecessary work, however. :(

Re: A French Book Reading Resource

Posted: Tue Mar 05, 2019 1:56 am
by Carmody
zjones

Thank you very much for your very excellent question. It is what this thread is about. I want people to share what they like and don’t like in book reading so I can learn from others. So thank you.

You like books simple…. “something that's easy to read and sensitive. If you are going for Delf B1 you must be pretty accomplished. Your written and speaking skills sound excellent. I have heard you speak and was greatly impressed. However I am going to make some book suggestions and then we can go from there…

Books I have read
*** That were found to be especially outstanding.
HR= Highly recommended

L'Armoire Magique C.S. Lewis
Harry Potter, à l'école des sorciers J.K Rowling
Harry Potter et Le Prisonnier D'Azkaban J.K Rowling
Le Petit Prince Saint Exupery
Le Retour de l'Enfant Prodigy A. Gide***
Bonjour Tristesse F. Sagan*** HR
L'Amant Marguerite Duras*** HR
L'école des sorciers JK Rowling
Histoire du lion Personne S. Audeguy
L'homme qui plantait des arbres Jean Giono
Un Sac de Billes J. Joffo***
Sans famille H. Malot*** HR This has the advantage of a wonderful YouTube version
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FJP4Nx6vzVM&list=PLaMzSHCVzZaKILRk0PCO7ZErCr-XZ6E1N
I have seen all 50 episodes twice.

Also the following are excellent sources for finding books :
http://www.complete-review.com/reviews/
https://www.babelio.com/livres-/classique/28

I hope the suggestions are helpful.