reineke wrote:PeterMollenburg wrote:My recommondations are as follows.
1
2
3
4
5
6?
Assuming one skips no. 3 is that suggested warm up before FSI? Don't you think you're overdoing it with courses? I won't discuss Michel Thomas but I see that Cainntear just couldn't resist. It sure brings back memories
Some clarification on your statement would help. Do you mean
me? That I am doing too many? Or I am
suggesting too many? And suggesting too many why? Because the OP only asked for one suggestion only? I didn't suggest FSI, but I'm aiming to do it.
I wasn't suggesting one had to do all of the courses on the list either, I was listing what I thought were some of the better ones. If the OP was in fact me and I was telling me what to do, I probably would've recommended around 20 to 30 courses- because I like doing them. I like structure, I like the build up, I like shadowing increasingly more complucated dialogues in which I gradually assimilate the vocabularly and gain an understanding of the grammar. If you or anyone else doesn't like this, who am I to say you're learning techniques aren't right?
Pimsleur and MT are really very small courses even with all levels included and can even be done while commuting. After that I really only made one 'strong' recommendation- Assimil NFWE, as the others were depending on what the OP was looking for.
I don't think it's overkill to recommend Pimsleur, MT and Assimil NFWE. I think courses have a good place. I know I am very much in favour of them, while others will only use native materials. A balance, particularly in the early stages, is probably suited to the average student, but the OP was asking about courses, something whether it is 'good' or 'bad' I have experience with.
Let's say we were learning to play basketball and wanted to become 'advanced' at it. Many people will just 'play' basketball from the beginning and figure it out as they go because ultimately they just want to play the game. Others will practise all kinds of drills, do cross-training and work on things such as their vertical leap for varied amounts of time. I am this kind. I like the drills, the practise etc probably because I fall into the trap I admit of wanting to play a perfect game, but that's me.