Sonjaconjota wrote:Is this a good idea, or are there any reasons against it?
I think this is a bad idea for two reasons. 1) Learning kanji upfront like this requires you to review it regularly just to stay on top of it. 2) Having no other facet of the language to reinforce it makes it much harder to memorize and recall it.
In fact, these are the same reasons why I stopped recommending people learn “all” the kanji in a short period of time right when they start learning the language. I did this myself, using Heisig. It was years before I finally had all the kanji in play in my “normal” reading and writing, so I did tons of reviews just to stay on top of the ones not yet in use, which was a waste of time. And of course, the ones I hadn’t started to use were the hardest ones to memorize/recall.
So if I had to do it all over again, this is what I’d do. I wouldn’t start learning kanji until I had 2 or 3 months practice with the other facets of the language (conversing, listening, pronunciation, grammar and reading/writing with kana). Then I would do the free pdf for Heisig, which contains the first 100 or so kanji, in order to learn how to use the method, which I think is great. Next, I would learn all the kanji for all the vocabulary I already knew. Finally, I would only learn kanji as I encounter them, meaning if I learned a new word, I would learn its kanji, but not sooner.